Motion 1: Justification of Closed-Source Comparisons (Passed)
Proposed by Andrea Tagliasacchi (Simon Fraser University, University of Toronto), Torsten Sattler (Czech Technical University in Prague), Marcus Brubaker (York University), Dmytro Mishkin (Czech Technical University in Prague), Kosta Derpanis (York University), Marc Pollefeys (ETH Zurich), Yasutaka Furukawa (Simon Fraser University), Konrad Shindler (ETH Zurich), Andreas Geiger (University of Tubingen), Kwang Moo Yi (University of British Columbia), David Lindell (University of Toronto), Or Litany (Technion), Eric Brachmann (Niantic), David Fleet (University of Toronto), Siyu Tang (ETH Zurich)
The PAMI TC recommends to the ICCV / CVPR Steering Committee: Effective with the CVPR 2025 conference, whenever a comparison of published research without publicly available code / data / pretrained models is requested (i.e., requiring re-implementation), it should be appropriately justified if used as a basis for a paper decision. This is unless this is a somewhat minor change to an already implemented method for which the code / data is available or re-implementing a method based on details provided by a publication is common practice in a sub-field. In any case, comparisons should only be requested if the publication and / or code has been available sufficiently ahead of the submission deadline.
Results for motion 1:
Yes: 1149
No: 111
Motion 2: Text-Only Rebuttals (Did Not Pass)
Proposed by Ramin Zabih (Cornell University)
The PAMI TC recommends to the ICCV / CVPR Steering Committee: All future editions of CVPR and ICCV should limit the rebuttal to text only, following best practices from SIGGRAPH, in order to better prevent reviewers from requesting additional experiments in the rebuttal.
Results for motion 2:
No: 768
Yes: 479
Motion 3: The Location of ICCV 2029 (Passed)
Proposed by Gerard Medioni (Chair of the ICCV/CVPR Steering Committee)
The ICCV / CVPR Steering Committee made a preliminary decision to hold ICCV 2029 in Dubai, with ICCV 2031 to be held in Europe. Following the discussion held during the PAMI TC meeting, please vote whether or not to recommend that the Steering Committee move forward with the Dubai venue for ICCV 2029.
Results for motion 3:
Yes: 751
No: 497